After eight years, a long night bus ride, and a rather poky JR service to a ferry sailing beneath a bona fide double rainbow, I've made it to Naoshima, the chief of the art islands of the inland sea. After some folderol with internet service and missing the previous ferry by all of two minutes, Spike & I wound up eating out of a conbini for dinner last night, and this morning we took a late start, with the advantage that we had our hostel (a residence so recently converted it still has the former owner's nameplate on the doorpost and their family altar behind a curtain in the alcove) mostly to ourselves.
We hiked out (well actually, took the bus, since it is hot and I am attempting to not walk my knee to death, as I have done twice now this year already) to the Chichu Art Museum at the top of the hill, and I thought it was pretty cool. Like most of the major galleries on the art islands it was done by Ando Tadao, who is possibly my favorite living architect, and it uses almost entirely natural light and is also almost entirely underground--you'd hardly know it, since it's done so cleverly to let in as much natural light as possible, which also makes the entire museum itself a site-specific installation that changes with daily conditions. The weather was changeable today, though not drastically so, but enough to get something of a sense.
The museum only has works by three artists: Monet, Walter De Maria, and James Turrell. It was, as far as I can remember, my first encounter with De Maria and Turrell's stuff, of which more anon, but Monet was probably the first artist I learned to appreciate and like as an individual, and I've always loved his works; it helps that just about every one of them is a gem. The gallery has five Monets, all late period, all water lilies, one monumental, two square, two smaller and rectangular, designed to evoke the Musee de l'Orangerie of which they were a part. You have to put on slippers before you can walk into the gallery, which is floored in tumbled cubes of Italian marble (we were informed), and frankly, more art should be contemplated while wearing slippers. It was quiet, and that quiet really added to the experience.
The Walter De Maria piece was set in a two-story gallery, much like a church, with a 2.2m-diameter sphere of marble in the center between two flights of stairs and 27 wooden, gold-leafed sculptures of geometric shapes. I'm totally stealing it for a Stargate fanfic at some point--it was more than a little otherworldly, and very cool, to walk up those steps and then back down again, past the smooth, reflective marble sphere, in which you could always see the skylight. We walked past another Walter De Maria piece outside using some of the same elements, and it was also cool, but witty, in that it was tucked into the side of a staircase built into a hill. I was reminded a little of the scene at the end of the Sesame Street movie set in the Met, where the kid has to climb the stairs so that Osiris can weigh his heart in the scales.
The James Turrell pieces were, quite simply, stunning, particularly "Open Field," which played with light and space to alter viewers' perceptions, and then alter them further by allowing us to go, guided, inside the artwork, which didn't make it any less trippy or brain-bending: quite the opposite, in fact. Later in the afternoon we saw another Turrell artwork in the Minamidera art house, which also played with our perceptions, but instead of using light to do so, used darkness. Both times, walking back out into the world was like a revelation. I was reminded a little of LaMonte Young's Dream House, in all the best ways. I am an instant Turrell fan.
After that we trekked back down the hill--Yayoi Kusama's yellow pumpkin sculpture, ahoy!--and then into Honmura town, where we had a lovely vegetarian lunch in a tiny house cafe and set about seeing five of the six parts of the art house project (actually there are seven, but I failed to book the seventh in advance) in just under an hour. The aforementioned Minamidera, housed in an Ando-designed house, was the best, but I also really liked Kadoya, which has a number of counters appearing to float inside a darkened traditional house--again, I had a lot of thoughts about the sea of time and other notions. Haisha, which has a partial Statue of Liberty replica in it, was also a hoot, and the Go'o Shrine, which included an underground chamber with a glass staircase uniting heaven and earth, was also pretty cool, and very Old Kingdom, as Spike remarked. Gokaido was a bit subtle--the camellia tree element is key, but I suspect much is gained from knowing that the camellia tree has long associations as a Buddhist symbol of the transience of life. The rock garden was lovely, though. We missed Ishibashi and Kinza; next time.
Spike was generally less impressed by all of this than I was, and in fact we are now going to cut short our art island excursion and go to Takamatsu for udon on Friday, rather than hitting Teshima as I had originally planned. I wouldn't go so far as to say that the art islands are a scam--I have been very satisfied with all this so far, but I won't deny that the Benesse Foundation's orchestration of all this is a bit…not quite heavy-handed, but definitely institutional. We noticed while wandering around Honmura a series of witty yarn artworks, which turned out to be done by one Ishikawa Kazuhara, who just started doing his art here in 2006 after someone told him he should. (I suspect this isn't quite yarn-bombing; he visits to maintain the art once a year.) Despite the fact that there is now a brochure with a map of all his pieces, there is something much more charming about their extreme site specificity and spontaneity that the Benesse-brokered art simply can't match.
I would love to get out here for the Setouchi Triennale next year, when even more of the islands will be transformed into art; I would love to come back; I'm really looking forward to Inujima tomorrow. Still, the contrast between my own unconscious expectations and the reality continues to intrigue me.
We hiked out (well actually, took the bus, since it is hot and I am attempting to not walk my knee to death, as I have done twice now this year already) to the Chichu Art Museum at the top of the hill, and I thought it was pretty cool. Like most of the major galleries on the art islands it was done by Ando Tadao, who is possibly my favorite living architect, and it uses almost entirely natural light and is also almost entirely underground--you'd hardly know it, since it's done so cleverly to let in as much natural light as possible, which also makes the entire museum itself a site-specific installation that changes with daily conditions. The weather was changeable today, though not drastically so, but enough to get something of a sense.
The museum only has works by three artists: Monet, Walter De Maria, and James Turrell. It was, as far as I can remember, my first encounter with De Maria and Turrell's stuff, of which more anon, but Monet was probably the first artist I learned to appreciate and like as an individual, and I've always loved his works; it helps that just about every one of them is a gem. The gallery has five Monets, all late period, all water lilies, one monumental, two square, two smaller and rectangular, designed to evoke the Musee de l'Orangerie of which they were a part. You have to put on slippers before you can walk into the gallery, which is floored in tumbled cubes of Italian marble (we were informed), and frankly, more art should be contemplated while wearing slippers. It was quiet, and that quiet really added to the experience.
The Walter De Maria piece was set in a two-story gallery, much like a church, with a 2.2m-diameter sphere of marble in the center between two flights of stairs and 27 wooden, gold-leafed sculptures of geometric shapes. I'm totally stealing it for a Stargate fanfic at some point--it was more than a little otherworldly, and very cool, to walk up those steps and then back down again, past the smooth, reflective marble sphere, in which you could always see the skylight. We walked past another Walter De Maria piece outside using some of the same elements, and it was also cool, but witty, in that it was tucked into the side of a staircase built into a hill. I was reminded a little of the scene at the end of the Sesame Street movie set in the Met, where the kid has to climb the stairs so that Osiris can weigh his heart in the scales.
The James Turrell pieces were, quite simply, stunning, particularly "Open Field," which played with light and space to alter viewers' perceptions, and then alter them further by allowing us to go, guided, inside the artwork, which didn't make it any less trippy or brain-bending: quite the opposite, in fact. Later in the afternoon we saw another Turrell artwork in the Minamidera art house, which also played with our perceptions, but instead of using light to do so, used darkness. Both times, walking back out into the world was like a revelation. I was reminded a little of LaMonte Young's Dream House, in all the best ways. I am an instant Turrell fan.
After that we trekked back down the hill--Yayoi Kusama's yellow pumpkin sculpture, ahoy!--and then into Honmura town, where we had a lovely vegetarian lunch in a tiny house cafe and set about seeing five of the six parts of the art house project (actually there are seven, but I failed to book the seventh in advance) in just under an hour. The aforementioned Minamidera, housed in an Ando-designed house, was the best, but I also really liked Kadoya, which has a number of counters appearing to float inside a darkened traditional house--again, I had a lot of thoughts about the sea of time and other notions. Haisha, which has a partial Statue of Liberty replica in it, was also a hoot, and the Go'o Shrine, which included an underground chamber with a glass staircase uniting heaven and earth, was also pretty cool, and very Old Kingdom, as Spike remarked. Gokaido was a bit subtle--the camellia tree element is key, but I suspect much is gained from knowing that the camellia tree has long associations as a Buddhist symbol of the transience of life. The rock garden was lovely, though. We missed Ishibashi and Kinza; next time.
Spike was generally less impressed by all of this than I was, and in fact we are now going to cut short our art island excursion and go to Takamatsu for udon on Friday, rather than hitting Teshima as I had originally planned. I wouldn't go so far as to say that the art islands are a scam--I have been very satisfied with all this so far, but I won't deny that the Benesse Foundation's orchestration of all this is a bit…not quite heavy-handed, but definitely institutional. We noticed while wandering around Honmura a series of witty yarn artworks, which turned out to be done by one Ishikawa Kazuhara, who just started doing his art here in 2006 after someone told him he should. (I suspect this isn't quite yarn-bombing; he visits to maintain the art once a year.) Despite the fact that there is now a brochure with a map of all his pieces, there is something much more charming about their extreme site specificity and spontaneity that the Benesse-brokered art simply can't match.
I would love to get out here for the Setouchi Triennale next year, when even more of the islands will be transformed into art; I would love to come back; I'm really looking forward to Inujima tomorrow. Still, the contrast between my own unconscious expectations and the reality continues to intrigue me.